National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence - Orange County

Unnecessary Debate: Is Addiction a Disease?

Unnecessary Debate: Is Addiction a Disease? Imagine two stalwart fans of professional wrestling locked in debate. One holds that the wrestlers are athletes. The other argues that they are not athletes but entertainers, performing in a variety of theater. Both fans are thoughtful and persuasive. Notice that their disagreement is not about the physical attributes of professional wrestlers, or about what they do inside and outside the ring. Their disagreement is about how to name, or classify, the group of people who engage in professional wrestling. Professional wrestlers are what they are and do what they do.  Naming and classifying, however, are conceptual, and therefore somewhat arbitrary.  This arbitrariness is no revelation.  As Shakespeare’s Juliet said:  What's in a name? that which we call a rose By any other name would smell as sweet But when debates about classification heat up, people often think and act as if the issues are absolute rather than arbitrary, especially if......

Read Original Text